by Ram ben Ze'ev
The death of former President Jimmy Carter marks the end of a political life that many heralded as humble and peace-driven. However, a closer examination of his actions reveals a legacy marred by interference in Israel’s sovereignty, promotion of theological condescension towards Judaism, and a peace agreement with Egypt that proved more illusionary than substantive.
Carter's presidency (1977-1981) and post-presidency activism were underscored by his constant meddling in Israeli affairs. His 2006 book, Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid, accused Israel of systemic oppression, blatantly ignoring the constant threats Israelis face from terrorism. Carter's skewed narrative not only inflamed anti-Israel sentiments but also fueled global hostility against the Jewish state. His portrayal of Israel as the oppressor erased the sacrifices Israel has made in the pursuit of peace and ignored the complexities of the Middle East conflict.
Compounding his misguided political interventions was Carter’s overt religious agenda, particularly his role in evangelical movements targeting Jewish communities. Carter’s embrace of proselytization, with efforts to "convert" Jews, demonstrated a deep-rooted ignorance and disrespect for Jewish beliefs. His actions insinuated that Jews, who steadfastly maintain their covenant with G-D, were somehow "misguided." Such behavior exemplified a condescending worldview that prioritized his own convictions over centuries of Jewish tradition and resilience.
While many credit Carter for brokering the 1979 Camp David Accords between Israel and Egypt, the outcomes were far from beneficial for Israel in the long term. Egypt’s "peace" masked its ongoing complicity in smuggling weapons and aiding terrorist organizations in Gaza. Carter’s agreement failed to hold Egypt accountable, leaving Israel to deal with the repercussions of a peace partner acting in bad faith. The narrative of Carter as a peacemaker ignores the tangible harm his policies inflicted on the Jewish state.
Adding to the intrigue surrounding Carter’s death is the peculiar timing. Reports suggest that Carter may have passed away in July 2024, yet news of his death only surfaced later. The delay raises questions about whether information was suppressed to serve a political agenda, allowing Carter to fulfill his alleged desire to vote for Kamala Harris in the 2024 election. While this theory may draw skepticism, it aligns with an era rife with disinformation, where the mainstream media and government agencies often manipulate narratives to suit their ends. This situation epitomizes Gell-Mann Amnesia syndrome, where the public alternates between trusting and distrusting the same sources depending on how closely the narrative aligns with their personal beliefs.
Carter's legacy, touted by admirers as one of humility and faith, is better characterized by his inability to respect Israel’s sovereignty, his disregard for Jewish convictions, and his role in perpetuating shallow peace agreements. His death should be an occasion for sober reflection, not uncritical glorification.
###
Bill White (Ram ben Ze'ev) is CEO of WireNews Limited, Mayside Partners Limited, MEADHANAN Agency, Kestrel Assets Limited (developer of MAYCOINS), SpudsToGo Limited and Executive Director of Hebrew Synagogue