by Ram ben Ze'ev
New York City, a place often touted as a sanctuary for immigrants, has a long history of welcoming people from all walks of life. This reputation has been built on the city's commitment to sanctuary city policies, which are designed to protect undocumented immigrants from deportation and ensure their access to essential services. However, since taking office as mayor, Eric Adams has raised eyebrows with his seemingly contradictory stance on these policies. While he claims to support the idea of a sanctuary city, his actions and policies tell a different story.
Mayor Eric Adams campaigned on a promise of upholding New York City's status as a sanctuary city. He frequently voiced his commitment to protecting undocumented immigrants from the threat of deportation and ensuring they could access crucial services without fear. However, his actions as mayor have not matched his rhetoric.
One of the most glaring examples of Adams' hypocrisy is his approach to cooperating with federal immigration authorities. Despite pledging not to collaborate with Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), his administration has continued to do so, albeit in more subtle ways. Under his leadership, the NYPD has continued to share information with federal immigration authorities, undermining the very essence of a sanctuary city.
One of the central tenets of sanctuary city policies is refusing to honor ICE detainers, which are requests from federal authorities to hold individuals in custody for potential immigration enforcement. Adams promised that New York City would not comply with these detainers. Still, recent reports have shown that his administration has not been consistent in this regard. There have been instances where individuals with ICE detainers have been held in custody, directly contradicting his earlier statements.
Sanctuary city policies are designed to foster trust between law enforcement and immigrant communities. When undocumented immigrants believe that local law enforcement will not act as an arm of federal immigration authorities, they are more likely to report crimes, cooperate with investigations, and engage with city services. However, Adams' approach to policing has raised concerns about eroding this trust.
Adams has been a strong advocate for a more aggressive policing approach, including the controversial stop-and-frisk policy, which has disproportionately targeted communities of color and immigrant populations. These policies can create an environment of fear and mistrust among undocumented immigrants, deterring them from engaging with law enforcement when they are victims or witnesses of crimes.
---> Follow on Twitter/X @rambenzeev and read all of RAM's articles on X
New York City has been grappling with a severe homelessness crisis for years, affecting many immigrant communities. Mayor Adams has pledged to address this crisis, but his approach has come under scrutiny for its potential harm to undocumented individuals. His proposal to forcibly relocate homeless individuals from the streets and subways has raised concerns about how it may disproportionately affect undocumented immigrants without access to social services or shelter.
Another critical aspect of sanctuary city policies is ensuring that all residents, regardless of their immigration status, have access to gainful employment. Eric Adams' administration has been criticized for not doing enough to address the economic inequities faced by undocumented workers. This includes failing to provide adequate protections and support for workers, especially in industries where many undocumented immigrants are employed.
Despite his rhetoric and promises, Adams' administration has not introduced any significant new policies to protect the rights and well-being of undocumented immigrants. Instead, it has relied on existing measures, some of which are not consistently enforced.
New York City's status as a sanctuary city has long been a point of pride for its residents and a symbol of its commitment to inclusivity and diversity. Mayor Eric Adams, however, appears to be undermining the very principles that make the city a sanctuary for all. While he may speak eloquently about protecting undocumented immigrants, his actions as mayor reveal a troubling hypocrisy that threatens to erode trust within immigrant communities.
It is essential to hold public officials accountable for their actions and not simply accept their words at face value. As concerned citizens, we must scrutinize the policies and decisions of our leaders to ensure they align with the values and principles we hold dear. In the case of Mayor Eric Adams, his actions on sanctuary city policies do not match his rhetoric, and it is our responsibility to demand transparency, consistency, and genuine commitment to the ideals of a sanctuary city.
###
Bill White (Ram ben Ze'ev) is CEO of WireNews and Executive Director of Hebrew Synagogue