by Ram ben Ze'ev
In a world where belief systems are diverse and varied, the question of G-D's existence remains one of the most profound and debated topics. While some individuals assert their faith fervently, others resolutely deny the existence of a higher power. Yet, beneath the surface of this denial, there lies a fascinating argument: that everyone, even those who deny the existence of G-D, harbours an inherent belief in a divine presence. By exploring the universal sense of morality, the search for meaning, psychological projections, the longing for transcendence, and moments of dependency, we can uncover the subtle ways in which belief in G-D manifests within the human psyche. These dimensions should be explored, offering a compelling perspective on the hidden acknowledgment of G-D in all individuals, regardless of their professed beliefs.
---> Follow on Twitter/X @rambenzeev and read all of RAM's articles on X
The argument that everyone, even those who deny the existence of G-D, actually believes in G-D can be framed from a psychological and existential perspective. Here’s a condensed version of such an argument:
Innate Sense of Morality: Every human being possesses an intrinsic sense of right and wrong, often referred to as a moral compass. This sense of morality suggests an underlying universal moral order, which can be seen as indicative of a higher moral authority or divine presence. Even those who deny G-D often adhere to moral principles that implicitly acknowledge a higher standard.
Search for Meaning: Humans have an inherent desire to find meaning and purpose in life. This quest for meaning points towards an existential recognition of something greater than oneself, which many would argue is a form of acknowledging G-D or a divine principle.
Psychological Projection: The concept of denial itself can be indicative of underlying belief. When individuals adamantly deny the existence of G-D, it can be interpreted as a psychological defense mechanism. According to this view, the vehemence of denial reveals an internal struggle with the concept of G-D, implying an underlying belief.
Universal Longing for Transcendence: Across cultures and epochs, humans have demonstrated a consistent yearning for transcendence and connection with something beyond the material world. This universal longing can be seen as evidence of an inherent belief in a higher power or divine presence, even if it is not explicitly acknowledged.
The Argument from Dependency: Every human experiences moments of dependency and vulnerability, whether through seeking comfort in times of distress or awe in moments of beauty and grandeur. These experiences point to a subconscious recognition of a greater power or force that provides support and inspiration, which can be interpreted as a form of belief in G-D.
Thus, the argument posits that deep within the human psyche, there is an inherent acknowledgment of a higher power or divine presence, which manifests in various ways, even among those who explicitly deny the existence of G-D.
###
Bill White (Ram ben Ze'ev) is CEO of WireNews and Executive Director of Hebrew Synagogue